AVowels  Is after you?
Is after you?   ARE
They make you red in the face   ROUGES
Wedding creations   INLAWS
Place to chill   HOTTUB
Oldies but goodies:
First mate?   EVE
Head line   PART
Head lines?   EEG
Theme: add a vowel to a phrase yielding another phrase --- and the five entries are in vowel order!
Proof of quartz sales?   A
GATERECEIPTSBrewery’s best?   E
LITEBEERMaking a mess at a warehouse?   U
PENDINGCASES  NINE
NINE [Only a Yankees fan could have come up with that clue --- or answer it right off.] 
 Adventures
Adventures   ODYSSEYS [they are journeys that contain adventures]
RATING:  
Three grins = Excellent: Loved it; Two grins = Good: Enjoyed it; One grin = Satisfactory: A bit bland for my taste; One teardrop = Unsatisfying: No fun